2024 Old Republic Reviews: Home Warranties (2024)

Old Republic Home Warrantee allegedly engages in chronic fraud and conspiracy against warrantee holders w/ their vendors. Terms of contract is I pay their vendors $75 service fee upon completion of job. Then Old Rep changed the terms of their contract during the warrantee period where they bill my credit card $75 service fee in advance at the time I call in a claim, then their vendors come out, and Old Rep denies the claim! They have refused my last several claims yet bill me for each service chg. in what I see as a ploy to discourage me from filing any claims. Since they changed the terms of their policy, no one gets back to you to let you know the status of your claim (which is denied)... Read More

The first time making a claim and it’s going to cost me the warranty holder a crazy amount of money for my repair!

You will NEVER get a call back from this company....Been dealing with nothing but lies from the start. They always go back to "We need more information from the installer" or "Your part is on backorder". This is quite possibly the WORST company I have ever dealt with. The "my service request" page is worthless. It isn't even close to being accurate. We have been without AC for a month and a half now and my house is at 90 degrees inside. You ask to speak to a supervisor and they put you on hold for 20 minutes only to come back and tell you they will call you back as no one is avaialbe. Don't use this company!

Long story short, requested service on a packaged AC unit, Sent out a provider that said the package unit needs to be replaced. With "Ultimate Protection" Old Republic" refused to cover items included in Ultimate coverage. The reason I called for service (AC) versus why the unit needed to be replaced (Heat) on a combined package unit were not covered costs because even though its one unit, the heating side needed to be replaced so AC coverages were not covered. 20+ years of loyalty and that means nothing to Old Republic. It took them over a month to order the replacement unit because in their words on more than one occasion "someone didnt get the memo". Sure they read the comments and... Read More

I contacted Old Republic for simple leak in toilet. Contractor was sent out, he said he needed a part, requested $75.00 and said he would return when the part was in. After 1 week I tried to contact his company Everything Plumbing and no one answers and I could not leave a msg. I contacted OR and they said I would need to work directly with the plumbing Co. I called again and again, and ended up hiring an outside plumber not connected with OR to complete the job. So I was out the $75.00 5 Months later, I had a separate shower issue of valve not turning. Called OR, different Company is sent out APC plumbing he said he would need a part and would return. I said I would not pay until he... Read More

K

This is one of the worst home warranty companies. They will try to find ways to avoid paying for covered repairs. When my hot water heater failed, I had to replace the appliance. Old Republic refused to cover the repair/replacement because I chose a smaller sized tank to replace the huge tank that was in the home when I purchased it. Their response stated that the original tank was "over sized" and so they would not pay for the replacement. Since that time, I also had problems with them with other repairs that were covered in the policy but they identified an obscure reason for not covering the repair/replacement. If you are looking for a home warranty company, DO NOT select this one!

C

Old Republic sent a contractor to our home that damaged our cooktop. Old Republic's contractor was not reputable and doesn't have insurance. Old Republic informed us (Old Republic's paying customer) that we would have to sue the uninsured contractor to have the cooktop replaced. Old Republic has refused to make this situation right. Beware of selecting Old Republic as a home warranty company as their practices border on fraud.

These two days I have been so frustrated dealing with them. Short story. Our water heater is leaking, and we required a service. The plumber came and said we need a new one. Two days later no updates and then I called them. They told me there are modifications not covered by our plan and we need to pay over $800 out of our pocket. Those modifications include T&P, connect electricity and replace the ball valve water line. Yes, we bought a standard plan which covers water heater. Why we buy home warranty, we want to save money. But with this company, it turns out we have to pay more and spent more time dealing with them on phone (very long waiting time) and get very frustrated. And the... Read More

Current holder of a ORHW policy on a condo. Had troubles with our dishwasher which was covered. 3 months and 3 different repairman/companies later, and they still have not fixed the dishwasher. I know - you only have so many parts to replace. The last repairguy actually replaced EVERYTHING that could be replaced including pump, hoses, connections - literally everything that could be done. Still not working. ORHW's response - send another repairman. According to repairman #2, he already charged more than $600 in parts. A brand new dishwasher from Home Depot would cost about that much, forget labor, travel, and time lost with the unit. So now we're on the 3rd company. The name of that... Read More

B

Do not waste your money on this company. They leave you on hold for over 30 minutes; and then disconnect you. Very rude people to deal with on the phone. We have been trying for over 2 months to get reimbursem*nt for our air conditioner. Horrible customer service.